Skip to main content
Hospital for Special Surgery Logo
phone 1.212.606.1000
Make an Appointment
1.212.606.1000 Make an Appointment
Back to Patient Stories Overview
Alexandra Chmil

Alexandra Chmil

Garden City, NY

Meniscus Tear (Torn Meniscus)

Alexandra Chmil

My experience at Hospital For Special Surgery is how I got back in the game. I rowed in high school and in college division 1. However, my senior year of high school I had to sit out my senior season because I tore my meniscus and plica in my right knee. I went to physical therapy and had numerous cortisone shots but it was not until Dr. O'Brien told me I had to take a break from rowing if I wanted my knee to get better. I continued to row in college until my junior year of college when I tore my plica again and also this time there was some scar tissue from the previous surgery. The second surgery was different because by then Dr. O'Brien told me I should be put on pain management. I was told to continue physical therapy not just going to the physical rehab place for my knee but swimming, biking, and walking I was told I can do to heal my knee. With some exercises and some more cortisone shots I was on my way to a speedy recovery. As a result of retearing my plica I had to quit rowing and I was disappointed but I continued to train as if I was on the team. I would go to practices and go on the bike but not lift like I did when I was on my college team. Dr. O'Brien did such a great job on my right knee to this day it hurts a little due to "when there's bad weather", but Dr. O'Brien knew that getting my range of motion back in order was a huge priority. To this date, I can walk with minimal pain and full range of motion in my right knee. The recovery for my surgery was only about a month and the surgery was an outpatient surgery so I had my knee surgery in the morning then I left the Hospital for Special Surgery later that day. I also had surgery on my left knee. This too was from rowing. I tore my meniscus with blistering of the scar tissue causing irritation and pain. I really have to thank Dr. O'Brien for literally repairing my knees as he did especially at a such a young age when I was in high school then in college during my surgeries. I still have pain in my left knee but I have had about 10 cortisone shots and when I went to physical therapy for my knee. On the days my knee is hurting a lot I walk or bike or now that the weather is warmer I swim. During the spring and summer seasons I am a member a masters rowing program. However, I became educated about the tolerance of pain to my knee and what exercises not to do when I am in a great deal of pain. 1 day out of knee surgery I was on crutches with minimal weight bearing using my circulated iced knee brace with an attached ice bucket. 2 weeks out of my left knee surgery I was limping around with 1 crutch sometimes 2 if I absolutely needed them. I have since then gotten sneaker orthotics through a foot doctor to correct the alignment of my feet. I was able to get back in the game with the help of Dr. O'Brien and the Hospital for Special Surgery I know that as much as I love rowing there are going to be certain days when I simply cannot go rowing due to my knee pain.

HSS Providers

Stephen J. O'Brien, MD, MBA

Stephen J. O'Brien, MD, MBA

Sports Medicine Surgeon

Schedule a virtual or in-person appointment with an HSS specialist today. Start your request online or call 1.800.796.0482.

Make an Appointment