Skip to main content
Hospital for Special Surgery Logo
phone 1.212.606.1000
Make an Appointment
1.212.606.1000 Make an Appointment
Back to Patient Stories Overview
Caitlin Alexander

Caitlin Alexander

New York, NY

ACL Tear (Torn ACL)

Caitlin Alexander

When I first walked into Dr. John MacGillivray's office on crutches, it took him 10 seconds to diagnose my injury. Complete ACL tear. I broke down in tears right there in the patient room, thinking that this was a career ending injury. A competitive triathlete, I go on 50-100 mile bike rides routinely. One Saturday afternoon in the fall of 2013, I was bike commuting home in Manhattan when I was doored by a cab, knocking me off my bike and completely severing my ACL in my knee. Everything seemed unreal, like a bad dream I wanted to wake up from. Dr. MacGillivray eased my stresses and anxiety and assured me everything would be just fine and I would be back up and running in no time. The biggest thing I was worried about was that I had signed up (before my accident) for my very first Ironman the next summer. He again assured me I could get to that starting line. My experience on the day of the surgery was impeccable. From the lighthearted anesthesiologist to the caring nurses and the physical therapists, I felt comfortable and at ease. Everyone had such a positive and happy attitude and it was contagious! Thanks to Dr. MacGillivray's impeccable skills, my recovery was quick and much easier than I thought it would be. And sure enough, 10 months post-op, I ran across the finish line of my very first Ironman in 11 hours and 47 minutes. I owe so much to Dr. MacGillivray and HSS.

HSS Providers

John D. MacGillivray, MD

John D. MacGillivray, MD

Sports Medicine Surgeon

Schedule a virtual or in-person appointment with an HSS specialist today. Start your request online or call 1.800.796.0482.

Make an Appointment