Femur Fractures in Children: Treating a Child’s Broken Thighbone

John S. Blanco, MD
John S. Blanco, MD

Associate Attending Orthopaedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery
Associate Professor of Orthopaedic Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College

Emily R. Dodwell, MD, MPH, FRCSC
Emily R. Dodwell, MD, MPH, FRCSC

Assistant Attending Pediatric Orthopedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery
Assistant Professor of Orthopedic Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College

Shevaun Mackie Doyle, MD
Shevaun Mackie Doyle, MD

Associate Attending Orthopaedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery
Associate Professor of Orthopaedic Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College

Daniel W. Green, MD, MS, FAAP, FACS
Daniel W. Green, MD, MS, FAAP, FACS
Attending Orthopedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery
Professor of Clinical Orthopaedic Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College
David M. Scher, MD
David M. Scher, MD

Associate Attending Orthopedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery
Associate Professor, Clinical Orthopedic Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College

Ernest L. Sink, MD
Ernest L. Sink, MD

Associate Attending Orthopaedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery
Co-Director, Center for Hip Preservation, Hospital for Special Surgery

Roger F. Widmann, MD
Roger F. Widmann, MD

Chief, Pediatric Orthopaedic Surgery, Hospital for Special Surgery
Attending Orthopaedic Surgeon, Hospital for Special Surgery


Despite the size and strength of the femur (the bone in the thigh), fractures in childhood are not uncommon. A motor vehicle accident, a fall from a piece of playground equipment, or even a piece of furniture at home may result in a broken leg that can range in severity from a simple hairline crack to a complex injury that also involves damage to surrounding soft tissues.


As in adults, treatment goals for children include achieving proper realignment of the bone, promoting rapid healing, and returning the patient to normal activities. However, there are also unique factors and considerations in the treatment of broken bones in children. These factors include:

  • The configuration of the fracture
  • The ‘energy’ of the injury
  • The amount of soft tissue injury present
  • The patient’s size and age
  • The amount of growth the child has remaining
  • The potential for any shortening of the bone that can sometimes occur with a fracture of a growing bone

Newborns and Infants

Femur fractures in newborns are unusual, but can occur, for example, in babies born with a skeletal dysplasia such as osteogenesis imperfecta - also known as brittle bone disease - or sometimes following a very difficult delivery. Fractures in these very young children and in infants are usually treated by placing the child in a Pavlik harness, (Figure 1) a cloth brace that helps hold the thigh in the proper position while it heals. “At this young age, children’s bones heal very rapidly, usually by 3-4 weeks,” says David M. Scher, MD, Associate Orthopedic Surgeon at Hospital for Special Surgery.

Figure 1: Image of Pavlik harness on a child with developmental hip dysplasia.


Unlike the healing process in adults, a certain amount of variation in alignment of the bone as it heals is acceptable in infants and older children, notes Dr. Scher. As the body lays down new bone, over time, there is an automatic “correction” or straightening during growth, called remodeling.


Toddlers to Age 5

The Spica Cast
Among children in this age group, femur fractures usually result from a low energy fall. In most cases, the orthopedic surgeon realigns the fracture using fluoroscopy or x-ray imaging as a guide and immobilizes the leg in a type of cast called a spica cast. This procedure takes place in the operating room and a pediatric anesthesiologist is present to administer a sedative or general anesthesia to keep the child comfortable.

While casting techniques vary among orthopedic surgeons, for femur fractures, the spica cast usually extends from mid-chest down the length of the affected leg and halfway down the other leg. “This allows us to best control the fracture and keep it from shifting out of place,” explains Dr. Scher.

Figure 2: A young patient in a spica cast, which immobilizes the leg after realignment.


Children remain in the spica cast for a period ranging from six weeks to three months, which can be challenge for caregivers when it comes to maintaining hygiene and keeping the child distracted and happy. That being said, it continues to be the safest and least complicated method for treating fractures among this age group and yields excellent results.


Figures 3, 4:  X-ray of a femur fracture with spica cast (top),
and 10 months after injury and removal of spica cast (bottom).
[Click on the images to view in a larger size.]

Following treatment, the orthopedic surgeon continues to monitor the patient for a period of several years to ensure that there is no limb length discrepancy. “When a fracture in the shaft of the femur occurs, the bone tends to shorten at the point where it breaks, Dr. Scher explains. “Later on, as healing occurs among children in this age group, the bone tends to grow longer; this is a phenomenon called “overgrowth” that may be caused by increased blood flow to the fracture site.”

In some patients this initial shortening, combined with the subsequent increased growth, “cancel” one another out. However, in those cases where a small limb length discrepancy occurs, the orthopedic surgeon can use a relatively simple technique, such as growth modulation of the longer leg, to address this issue.

Age 5 to 10 years

Intramedullary Nails or Rods
Over the last decade many pediatric orthopedists have started using intramedullary nails or rods made from strong, lightweight, and flexible titanium to stabilize femur fractures in children aged five and older. In a relatively simple technique, the orthopedic surgeon makes two small incisions - about one inch in length - on either side of the knee. After the bone is realigned, the nails are inserted up through the center of the bone where they act as an internal splint during healing.

Figure 5:  X-ray showing flexible intramedullary nails in place.
[Click on the image to view in a larger size.]

Intramedullary nails come in a range of diameters to accommodate the varying size of children’s bones. “Generally no casting is necessary,” Dr. Scher says, however a knee immobilizer is commonly used for a few weeks to prevent movement and to keep the child comfortable. In most cases, three to six weeks of early healing is necessary before the child can begin walking on the injured leg. When the bone is completely healed, usually around one year after the injury occurs, the child returns to the hospital to have the nails removed.

“Intramedullary nails are usually very well-tolerated,” says Dr. Scher. “They are particularly useful in five- to ten-year-old children who have a thick lining around the bone called the periosteum, which might be likened to the peel on a banana. The periosteum helps keep the bone more stable and reduces the need for a heavy and rigid device, such as those that might be used in adults.”

Older children and adolescents

Intramedullary nailing can also work well in older or heavier children, typically those over age 10 and heavier than 100 pounds; however, a single, thicker, more rigid nail is used rather than the smaller flexible nails. In these children, the nail is inserted through the top of the femur, near the hip, at a point called the greater trochanter, and locked into place with a screw at the top and the bottom of the bone. This placement avoids interruption of blood flow to the ball of the hip joint, which can lead to disabling arthritis. These concerns are not present in adults because they have different anatomy. In order to minimize the risk of complications when using intramedullary nailing in children, the orthopedist uses different devices and techniques than they would use in adult patients.

Figure 6:  X-ray showing a rigid intramedullary nail in place.
[Click on the image to view in a larger size.]

Submuscular Plating
Submuscular plating is another treatment option for older and larger children. In this procedure, using x-ray images for guidance, the orthopedic surgeon inserts a stainless steel plate under the muscles of the leg and across the fracture site. Through small incisions in the skin, screws are placed through the plate and bone, above and below the fracture to hold it in place. Although this technique is minimally invasive, removal of the plate is more difficult than removal of intramedullary nails. “Currently, there is some discussion ongoing in the orthopedic community regarding the need to remove the plates at all,” Dr. Scher says.

External Fixation
In addition to the approaches described, the fallback treatment for a femur fracture in any age child is external fixation. This technique involves the use of rigid metal rods or circular rings and pins inserted into the bone to maintain alignment during healing.

Figure 7:  An external fixation ("ex-fix") device worn by a patient.

The Evolution of Treatment

The use of intramedullary nails, external fixators, and other stabilization devices represent a dramatic improvement over the traditional approach to fractures of the femur. As recently as 20 years ago, the standard approach for most children over the age of two years was placement of a pin through the bone just above the knee and traction; this typically involved a hospital stay of three weeks or longer in which many adjustments were needed to maintain alignment. Traction was followed by placement in a body cast for as long as three months.

While this method resulted in excellent healing, proper alignment, and strong bones, it also required significant involvement on the part of a parent or other caregiver. “Fortunately, the available technology and our surgical skills have advanced to a point where we can achieve these same results in a more time-efficient manner which is much less disruptive to the family,” says Dr. Scher. “Today we are able to make our treatment decisions based not only on how we can best get the fracture to heal, but also on choosing the method that will be best tolerated by the child and his or her family.”

If you would like more information about the Pediatric Orthopedic Service at HSS, please visit the Physician Referral Service or call 1.877.606.1555.

Summary by Nancy Novick


Departments and Services

Back in the Game Patient Stories: