Skip to main content
Hospital for Special Surgery Logo
phone 1.212.606.1000
Make an Appointment
1.212.606.1000 Make an Appointment
Back to Patient Stories Overview
Molly McCarthy

Molly McCarthy

Pittsford, NY

Molly McCarthy

I came to HSS in August 2014 after having an unsuccessful surgery for Achilles and ankle pain in my hometown. I was in terrible pain, unable to walk and desperate for an answer. A dear friend who had surgery with a foot and ankle surgeon at HSS said, "call his office manager at HSS. She'll get you an appointment with him. He will help you." So I made the call. Susanne asked if I could be there the next day. "Like tomorrow?," I asked. "That's a long 6 hour drive from Rochester, NY!" Susanne responded, "well it's 6 hours whether you come now or a month from now." So early the next morning, we were on the road to NYC. After a misdiagnosis, an unsuccessful surgery and no solution in sight, I had almost given up hope on getting my active lifestyle back. Enter the HSS Team.

Within minutes of our arrival, I was in the exam room. I was treated with such respect. After looking at my MRI and doing an examination, he identified many abnormalities . Everything made sense. His explanations were clear and I had no doubt whatsoever that he could get me moving again. Within a month, I had ankle surgery which involved removal of several cysts, repair of a loose ligament, 2 allografts, a stem cell treatment and later a PRP injection to promote healing. My HSS Team provided such amazing care and expertise.

But, as it turns out, I wasn't quite ready to get back in the game. The stress of 2 ankle surgeries was too much for a bum knee. Elated following the success of my ankle reconstruction, I contacted my surgeon's amazingly energetic and talented PA. He was a godsend after my ankle reconstruction answering numerous questions and reassuring me. He recommended several knee surgeons, including Dr. David Mayman. I contacted Dr. Mayman's office, spoke to Heather and arranged an appointment. Dr. Mayman was easy to talk to. We had a discussion on which option was better for me and I chose a partial knee replacement. He agreed. So seven months after my ankle reconstruction, I was back at HSS for a partial knee replacement. The day after surgery, my bone to bone pain was gone. Two weeks later, I needed little assistance to walk and now 8 months later, I'm back in the game, walking my dog, riding my bike, gardening, hiking, golfing and more; things I feared I would never do again.

My heartfelt gratitude goes out to Dr. Mayman and all the wonderful people at HSS as well Cathy Hill, my PT in Rochester. After 9 trips to NYC for surgery and follow ups, I would do it all over again. The work being done at HSS is truly groundbreaking and inspiring. Thanks to everyone for getting me back in the game!

HSS Providers

David J. Mayman, MD

David J. Mayman, MD

Hip and Knee Replacement Surgeon

Schedule a virtual or in-person appointment with an HSS specialist today. Start your request online or call 1.800.796.0482.

Make an Appointment