Meniscus Tears 101

Whether you are an athlete or a weekend warrior, being aware of how to prevent injuries are of the utmost importance. Meniscus tears can occur in people of all ages!

What is a meniscus? There are actually two menisci in each knee that distribute the weight of the body and reduce friction in the knee.  The menisci sit in the knee joint between the femur and the tibia along with cartilage, a smooth, gliding layer that allows pain-free motion at the joint. The menisci are crescent-shaped fibrocartilage structures that protect the cartilage from damage and allow the joint to continue to move freely.  The meniscus on the medial (inside) part of the knee is larger and the meniscus on the lateral (outside) part of the knee is smaller and more circular.  Toward the central part of the knee, each of the menisci are attached to the tibia in the front and back.  The shape and attachments of the menisci within the knee are essential to the function of protecting the cartilage in the knee from damage with activity such as walking, running, and playing sports.

How do meniscus tears occur? Meniscus tears can occur from an injury, ‘wear and tear’ or early arthritis of the knee.  Tears from an injury usually happen when a person twists awkwardly on the knee or has a collision or fall.  Meniscus tears from trauma can occur alone or in combination with ligament injuries.  Without an injury, meniscus tears can also occur, but the onset of pain is usually more gradual.  This typically happens in arthritis cases when the cartilage in the knee starts to get thin or wear out.  Meniscus tears can often be an early sign that the cartilage in the knee is not healthy.

What are common injury symptoms? Symptoms of a meniscus tear can include: pain on the knee joint over the meniscus, pain with bearing weight on the affected knee, pain with twisting, turning, or pivoting on the knee such as getting in and out of bed or a car.  The knee will often swell with a meniscus tear.

How are meniscus tears treated? Treatment of meniscus tears varies on the nature of the injury and the needs and demands of each patient.  Traumatic meniscus injuries are generally treated with surgery to either repair the meniscus or remove a portion of the meniscus that is no longer functional.  The meniscus only has a blood supply to certain parts and that blood supply decreases with age.  Therefore meniscus repair may not be appropriate for all meniscus injuries or all patient ages.  Recovery from meniscus surgery ranges from several weeks to several months and can include bracing, crutches, and physical therapy.  Meniscus tears that happen without an injury are typically treated with a period of rest, activity modification, ice, elevation, physical therapy, possible bracing, and occasionally an injection.  Sometimes these tears may also require surgical management.

If you suspect a meniscus tear, it is important to be evaluated by an orthopedic care provider so that the most appropriate treatment can be provided.


Dr. Moira McCarthy is an orthopedic surgeon specializing in sports medicine. She practices at both the HSS Outpatient Center in Stamford, CT and the hospital’s main campus in New York.

The information provided in this blog by HSS and our affiliated physicians is for general informational and educational purposes, and should not be considered medical advice for any individual problem you may have. This information is not a substitute for the professional judgment of a qualified health care provider who is familiar with the unique facts about your condition and medical history. You should always consult your health care provider prior to starting any new treatment, or terminating or changing any ongoing treatment. Every post on this blog is the opinion of the author and may not reflect the official position of HSS. Please contact us if we can be helpful in answering any questions or to arrange for a visit or consult.


  1. Dr. McCarthy, currently I have a meniscus tear on my inner right knee verified by MRI and X-ray, I’ve been getting various opinions on whether to get surgery, and I’m asking for your professional opinion please!!! Currently I’m a 40 y/o serving as a mobilized reservist in the American military, and when I’m not mobilized I’m a police officer. The physician assistant said its not wise for me to get surgery due to my age and my concerns, but the doctor said I should get surgery and that everyone heals differently. I’ve been dealing with this injury for three years now, there have been instances where I would feel pain if I overuse my knee, and I have noticed that I cannot use any type of shoes (football cleats) without souls because there is pain when I run. I continue to play sports and physical activity but at the same time I’m worried that one day my knee will go out. Please assist me on making my mind at ease that I’m doing the right thing….

    1. Hi Cyrus- Sounds like she should come in for an evaluation and second opinion. No reason a 40 year old shouldn’t have surgery. -Dr. McCarthy

    2. Hi Cyrus- Dr. Moira McCarthy will like you to schedule a visit to come in to see her for an evaluation of your meniscus tear. Please call our office at (203) 705-0900 to set up an appointment with Dr. Moira McCarthy. She sees patients in NYC and Stamford, CT. -Dr. McCarthy’s Office

  2. I wonder which one is the one that I have like wen I twist my knee from left to right it feels like each bone is making cintactvwith each other… And if I stand for too long it starts to hurt if I run one day the next day I can’t really stretch my leg because my knee be hurting..

    1. Hi Jaime- It is hard to make a diagnosis without an evaluation. Some of the complaints could be related to a meniscus issue but also possibly an arthritis issue. I recommend getting the knee evaluated. -Dr. McCarthy

If you’d like to consider HSS for treatment, please contact our Patient Referral Service at 888-720-1982. For general questions and comments, reach us on Facebook or Twitter.