> Skip repeated content

The Pros and Cons of Same-Day Double Knee Replacement Surgery

Dr. Geoffrey Westrich, hip & knee surgeon, in the operating room

Orthopedic surgeons perform almost 700,000 knee replacements in the United States each year, and the procedure has a high success rate in alleviating pain and restoring an active lifestyle. It’s not uncommon for patients to have arthritis in both knees, so they may need to decide, along with their surgeon, whether to have both knees replaced at the same time. The procedure, known as a bilateral knee replacement, has both pros and cons, which must be carefully weighed before a decision is made.

Pros of Bilateral Knee Replacement

  • Having both knees replaced at the same time enables patients to get back to their normal lives more quickly.
  • Patients have one surgery, one hospital stay and one course of rehabilitation.
  • Patients generally take less time off from work.

Cons of Bilateral Knee Replacement

  • Studies show there is a greater risk of complications, including cardiovascular problems and blood clots.
  • Patients lose more blood, so there is a higher rate of blood transfusions.
  • Recovery and rehabilitation are much more challenging because greater physical and emotional strain is placed on the body. Rehab is also more difficult because patients are unable to rely on a stable leg for support.
  • Patients who have a double knee replacement must go to a facility for rehab after surgery. After a single knee replacement, many individuals go straight home and have physical therapy at home.

The Best Candidates

With careful patient selection, the overall success rate is high for bilateral knee replacement. Candidates for the procedure must be in excellent health, aside from the arthritis, with no underlying medical problems. They must have no history of heart or lung disease. They also need to be psychologically prepared for the intensive rehabilitation double knee replacement entails.

At HSS, bilateral knee replacements are not performed in individuals over 75 years old due to the greater risk of complications in older patients. Same-day double knee replacement is also out of the question for individuals of any age with a serious medical condition. Severely overweight patients who have a BMI over 40 would not be candidates for the bilateral procedure.

Advances in Total Knee Replacement

Not long ago, many people thought that if you had one knee replaced, the pain and rehab would be so taxing you wouldn’t want to come back for surgery on the other knee. But with today’s advances in surgical techniques, anesthesia and pain management, the recovery for a single knee replacement at a high-volume joint replacement center is much easier and faster than it was in the past. At Hospital for Special Surgery, virtually every patient comes back for the second knee replacement, generally waiting at least three months in between surgeries.

Know What to Expect

Whether having two separate procedures or both knees replaced simultaneously, the orthopedic surgeon should have a detailed discussion with the patient about what to expect. Because of the special considerations involved in bilateral knee replacement, it’s especially important to choose a highly experienced orthopedic surgeon who specializes in joint replacement.

Patients should also choose a hospital that performs a high volume of joint replacements, such as HSS. The entire staff will be accustomed to dealing with the needs of patients before, during and after the surgery.

Knee replacement is a big step, but knowing the facts can help patients make an informed decision. After the surgery, most patients will tell you that in terms of arthritis pain relief and improved mobility, they wished they had done it sooner.

Westrich G white coat June 2015

Dr. Geoffrey Westrich, Orthopedic Surgeon, specializes in knee and knee replacement, including revision surgery and complex cases at Hospital for Special Surgery. He is director of research of the Adult Reconstruction and Joint Replacement Service at HSS.

The information provided in this blog by HSS and our affiliated physicians is for general informational and educational purposes, and should not be considered medical advice for any individual problem you may have. This information is not a substitute for the professional judgment of a qualified health care provider who is familiar with the unique facts about your condition and medical history. You should always consult your health care provider prior to starting any new treatment, or terminating or changing any ongoing treatment. Every post on this blog is the opinion of the author and may not reflect the official position of HSS. Please contact us if we can be helpful in answering any questions or to arrange for a visit or consult.